Bone Broth Chews vs. Collagen Chews for Dogs: What’s the Difference?

Bone broth has become a popular ingredient in the pet world, showing up in everything from food toppers and treats to long-lasting chews. But while bone broth chews and collagen chews may sound similar, they aren’t necessarily the same thing.

At Wag & Bright, we chose to build Mighty Marrows around collagen because we wanted to create a dog chew designed specifically for a long-lasting chewing experience and mechanical dental care.

What Are Bone Broth Chews for Dogs?

Bone broth is traditionally made by simmering animal bones and connective tissue over time. In pet products, bone broth may be used for flavour, nutrition, or as part of a larger ingredient blend.

When it comes to bone broth chews for dogs, formulas can vary widely between brands. Some may contain bone broth powder or flavouring alongside other ingredients, while others may use collagen or gelatin as part of the chew itself.

What Is a Collagen Chew?

Collagen chews are made using collagen as a key structural ingredient.

Mighty Marrows are made with a collagen and gelatin base that creates a firm chew when dry. As your dog chews, saliva gradually softens the outer layer into a gel-like texture.

That gradual softening is intentional. It allows dogs to gnaw at the chew over time, creating the mechanical chewing action that makes Mighty Marrows part of a preventative dental care routine.

Why We Chose a Collagen-First Formula.

When developing Mighty Marrows, our goal wasn’t to turn bone broth into a treat.

We wanted to create a limited-ingredient chew that was:

• Long lasting.

• Highly digestible.

• Rawhide free.

• Free from glycerine and unnecessary fillers.

• Designed to soften gradually while chewing.

• Suitable for multiple chewing sessions.

By building the chew around collagen, we were able to focus on texture, durability, and the chewing experience itself.

Are Bone Broth Chews and Collagen Chews the Same?

Not necessarily.

Bone broth chews and collagen chews may contain related animal-derived ingredients, but their formulas, textures, and intended uses can be very different.

“Bone broth” can mean different things depending on how it is made. The animal source, bones and connective tissues used, cooking time, concentration, and additional ingredients can all influence the final product. Seeing bone broth on an ingredient list does not necessarily tell you exactly how much collagen, protein, or other naturally occurring nutrients are present in the finished chew.

This is one reason we chose a collagen-first formula for Mighty Marrows: it allows us to be more intentional about the ingredients responsible for the chew’s structure, texture, and chewing experience.

Rather than focusing only on the name on the front of the package, it can be helpful to look at the ingredient list, how the chew is made, and what purpose it is designed to serve.

Choosing the Right Chew for Your Dog.

No chew is right for every dog.

When choosing a chew, consider your dog’s size, mouth size, chewing style, age, and dental history. Dogs should always be supervised while chewing, and the chew should be large enough for them to comfortably hold and gnaw rather than clamp down forcefully.

For dogs who are new to Mighty Marrows, the outer layer can also be pre-softened in warm water for approximately one minute before their first chewing session.

A Different Approach to the Dog Chew.

Bone broth products can be a great addition to the pet category, but Mighty Marrows were created with a different goal in mind.

We chose a collagen-first formula because we wanted a simple, functional, long-lasting chew designed around the physical act of chewing.

If you’re comparing bone broth chews for dogs with collagen chews, the biggest difference may simply come down to what ingredients are inside the chew.

Shop Mighty Marrows Collagen Dental Chews.